Engine Room Flooded Within 10–20 Minutes of the Grounding

513

Summary:

On March 6, 2017, about 0009, the uninspected commercial fishing vessel St. Dominick grounded in Pumicestone Bay, Alaska. The engine room flooded within 10–20 minutes of the grounding, and the four crewmembers abandoned the vessel a short time later. None of them were injured, and no pollution was reported. The vessel, valued at $1.1 million, was deemed a constructive total loss.

Findings:

Investigators could not determine, from the crew statements precisely, when the bridge watch alarm sounded after the vessel grounded. According to the captain, resetting the bridge watch alarm to 3 minutes, which was a routine, when the vessel completed fishing and was operating near land, could have prevented the accident.

Crewmembers also stated that they were tired and that the accident was caused by a “general lack of sleep.” A deckhand said that the crew, on average, got about 4–5 hours of rest per day. Investigators noted that this rest was spread between the daytime breaks from fishing and the nighttime cessation of all fishing operations.

The captain said, he would average between 4 and 6 hours of rest in a 48-hour period, which equates to about 2–3 hours per day. Further, the amount of sleep in a given day changes as, did the times that he slept. On March 4, he slept while the vessel offloaded and proceeded to the fishing area. Then, during the early morning of March 5, he slept for 1 to 1.5 hours.

In December 2014, the fishing vessel Titan grounded in the Columbia River and eventually sank near Cape Disappointment, Washington. As with the St. Dominick accident, the captain of the vessel had fallen asleep at the helm while the vessel was navigating through a bend in the channel. The NTSB investigated and determined that the captain failed to monitor the vessel’s track as a result of falling asleep due to an prolonged sleeplessness. Contributing to the accident was the nature of the derby-style fishing that the Titan was engaged in.

The circumstances in the St. Dominick accident were similar to the February 2015 grounding of the fishing vessel, Savannah Ray, which was also investigated by the NTSB. The Savannah Ray, while returning from a cod pot-fishing trip, grounded near the entrance of St. Paul Harbor, Kodiak Island, Alaska. Investigators determined that the captain fell asleep and failed to negotiate a critical turn. Investigators noted that the captain’s fatigue was likely due to insufficient sleep and because his sleep cycle was interrupted or non-consecutive.

As found in other NTSB investigations, open-access, derby-style fishing encourages working longer hours to increase the vessel’s portion of the overall quota set by state regulators. The St. Dominick captain and one of the deckhands stated that the rules for the cod fishery in which the vessel operated encouraged around-the-clock operations and contributed to inadequate rest.

Probable Cause:

The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of the grounding of the St. Dominick was the captain’s failure to monitor the vessel’s track as a result of his fatigue due to an prolonged sleeplessness. Contributing to the accident was the nature of the derby-style fishing that the St. Dominick was engaged in and the captain’s failure to properly set the bridge watch alarm.

Did you subscribe for our daily newsletter?

It’s Free! Click here to Subscribe!

Source: NTSB

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.