Innocent Lives Lost Due To Lockdown Isolation On Cruise Ships

Szaller had been working on Carnival ships since January, but the new coronavirus brought the industry to a halt. After pausing sailings in mid-March, Carnival Corp. and its main competitor, Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd., went to great lengths to repatriate vacationers, sending passengers home by chartered flights. Crew members didn’t receive the same treatment. After the guests went home, tens of thousands of workers stayed at sea for months. Some described feeling like prisoners or pieces of cargo with no ETA.

Disappearance 

It was May 9, a Saturday, when colleagues realized Szaller had missed his daily temperature checks. Friends said they hadn’t seen him since Wednesday. According to interviews with crew and official documents, a team was dispatched to check on him but found his cabin door blocked by something heavy. They managed to push it open a crack. A crew member reached through, felt a shoulder, and shook it. No response. Then they went into the adjacent room, stepped out onto the terrace, and, with the Atlantic Ocean swelling below, climbed over the railing onto Szaller’s balcony. Once inside his cabin, they found their colleague’s slumped body. Szaller’s face and arms were blue. Blood trailed from his mouth to his white T-shirt. A belt was around his neck.

The sad news

Two time zones away, in Domsod, Hungary, Jozsef’s parents, Vilmos and Ildiko, were tidying up their weekend cottage and stocking the fridge in anticipation of their son’s post-travel quarantine. They figured a countryside escape would buoy his spirits after his isolation at sea, and they’d be able to check in on him from their home near Budapest, an hour’s drive away. But when they returned home that evening, the police were waiting. An officer had Vilmos dial a Hungarian consulate in the U.S., which gave him a number for Carnival. He called and was put in touch with what sounded like a roomful of company representatives, along with a Hungarian-speaking interpreter. “They said they found my son dead on the ship,” Vilmos recalls.

He struggled to make sense of what he was hearing. Jozsef was 28 and in perfect health, at least as far as his parents knew. Something terrible must have happened. Was this an accident? Could foul play have been involved? Carnival offered few details. “We were told 15 times that we’re not being told for our protection,” Vilmos says.

Questions 

He says he pressed until something resembling a story emerged. “I asked them where they found the body,” he recalls. “They said, ‘In the room.’ Where in the room? On the bed? ‘No, not on the bed.’ In the bathroom? ‘Not in the bathroom.’ On the floor? Finally they said, ‘Yes, on the floor.’ ” They mentioned that crew had gone in by way of the balcony, so Vilmos figured that Jozsef had been pressed against the door, blocking their entrance. He asked whether a doorknob was involved—had his son hanged himself on it? “They didn’t clearly answer, but they kind of suggested it,” he says. Jozsef, as far as his parents could tell, had taken his own life.

Vilmos says communications with Carnival broke down soon after. As the Szallers tried to organize the retrieval of their son’s body, including figuring out which jurisdiction would have to declare him legally deceased, they began to see the cruise company as having had a role in their son’s death. Its labyrinthine corporate structure—a web of international entities designed to lower Carnival’s tax liability—compounded their grief.

“We are saddened by the passing of our crew member and extend our deepest sympathies to his family and loved ones,” says Chris Chiames, the chief communications officer for Carnival Cruise Line, the subsidiary that operates Carnival-branded ships. Chiames says that crew health and safety were a priority throughout their repatriation and that the company provided counseling resources and regular communications about self-care. He adds that Carnival supported the Szallers in returning Jozsef’s remains and personal belongings and responded to additional family concerns.

Arbitration

On Dec. 21, the Szallers served Carnival a demand for arbitration, alleging that the company forced Jozsef to stay in his cabin for prolonged periods, failed to routinely monitor his well-being despite days of absence, and didn’t provide adequate training on how to deal with the mental effects of isolation. Chiames says Carnival “made every effort to make this situation as comfortable as possible,” and that Jozsef’s interactions with onboard medical staff and human resources never suggested he was having mental health challenges. Chiames says the company would have taken quick action if there had been signs of trouble.

The Szaller family is seeking monetary damages, but Vilmos stresses that he’s interested only in the truth behind what caused this tragedy. “Nothing will bring back my child, but it may give us some peace,” he says. “If the cruise company did something wrong, then I don’t think we’ll ever find out, because it’s such a huge entity and there’s such a vast financial network behind it. They just ignore us.”

It’s a trend Dr. David Cates, of the University of Nebraska Medical Center, calls a “pandemic within the pandemic.” He cites a report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in August that showed a startling 11% of 5,470 adult respondents among the U.S. population had “seriously considered suicide” over a 30-day period this spring, compared with 4.3% in another large survey in 2018 who reported considering suicide during the previous 12 months. “Being stuck on a ship for an indeterminate amount of time, in a small space—that really checks all the boxes,” says Cates, who treated some of the first rescued cruise passengers at UNMC’s national quarantine center. In addition to the estimated 100 or so passengers and crew who died of causes linked to Covid, there have been at least a half-dozen other fatalities among crew members who were trapped at sea. Most of these are suspected suicides.

Interviews with affected crew members and their families suggest that despite assurances from cruise operators that crew were well cared for, their mental health was at times an afterthought. An October 2019 study on the mental well-being of crew, commissioned by a group affiliated with the International Transport Workers’ Federation, the big maritime trade union, found that even before the pandemic about a fifth of mariners surveyed said they had suicidal thoughts. High levels of depression stem from the jobs’ long contract lengths and stressful demands. Lower-level crew—such as junior housekeepers and galley staffers—often come from poorer countries and commit to half-year stints or longer at sea, working 8 to 10 hours, seven days a week. Their salaries can range from about $650 to $2,000 a month, depending on seniority. The pay per hour is low by American standards, but workers say that it’s more than they could earn at home and that they appreciate the opportunity to travel the world.

After the pandemic hit, workers had to put their lives on hold as Carnival and Royal Caribbean clashed with government authorities over how to get them home safely. It was one thing to offload a group of American passengers in California or Florida and arrange private transport stateside. But what about the convoluted logistics of repatriating crew from India, the Philippines, or Ukraine—all while most of the world was closing its borders to stop the virus’s spread?

Workers blamed the CDC for imposing onerous restrictions on travel, such as requiring company executives to sign off on a litany of health processes for disembarkation through U.S. harbors and airports at the risk of criminal penalties. But they also faulted cruise operators for seeming unwilling to pay for chartered flights abroad. A Carnival spokesperson says the conglomerate ended up spending $300 million and chartering 225 flights to get crew home to more than 100 countries, but fluctuating travel rules made it so “even the simplest crew movements required weeks of diplomatic work.” A Royal Caribbean spokesman says that “constant changes in government restrictions” caused delays and that they worked for months to get crew home through private and commercial transportation.

This left many crew members with a tedious confinement that started in March and April after passengers disembarked. The ships were eerie—like an “empty ghost ship,” as one Royal Caribbean worker puts it—especially for those who had to quarantine after being exposed to the coronavirus. For some, that meant being stuck for nearly three weeks in an economy room, one that barely fit a bunk bed, desk, and minifridge, with a porthole window.

It wasn’t just the claustrophobic environment that was distressing. Workers say cruise companies constantly changed repatriation schedules, offering only vague guidance on when or how they’d return home. Without customers on board, Carnival moved many contractors off duty, meaning they could sort of enjoy the amenities of the ocean liners. But that also meant their salaries were eventually cut off—a scary situation for those supporting families on land. The weeks dragged on with limited entertainment options. Internet access was complimentary on some boats, but it could be painfully slow or strong enough only for social media and texting.

Karika Neethling

Baby on board

 Karika Neethling, a shop employee on a luxury liner run by MSC Cruises SA, a big European operator, grew terrified upon learning she was pregnant while aboard the ship. The strong curries served to employees made her nauseous, and after developing stomach pain in May, she sought prenatal vitamins from the ship’s doctor. She was told they didn’t have any. “You just need to stay calm and stay in the cabin,” the doctor told her. Neethling recalls spending hours on her bunk, while her mind circled around the indefinite stay. She was in a dark place. “If I couldn’t get off, I wouldn’t have wanted to have a baby on the ship,” she says. (An MSC spokesperson said pregnant crew were provided extensive medical care and prioritized repatriation. Neethling made it home to South Africa in June and gave birth to a healthy baby boy on Dec. 17.)

More lives lost

On April 29, an electrical engineer from Poland on Royal Caribbean’s Jewel of the Seas disappeared while the ship was anchored in the Saronic Gulf, south of Athens. Ship security cameras captured him leaping into the water that morning, according to Greek authorities. Two weeks later, on May 10, Evgenia Pankrushyna, a waitress from Ukraine, died after jumping overboard from Carnival’s Regal Princess near Rotterdam. Around this time a Chinese contractor was found dead on Royal Caribbean’s Mariner of the Seas. A crew member aboard the ship says many believed it was another suicide, though the company said he’d died of natural causes. Next was a Filipino cook, Kennex Bundaon, who was found dead in his cabin on Carnival’s AIDAblu. Four days later, another worker from the Philippines died in an apparent suicide on Virgin Voyages’ Scarlet Lady. (Virgin Voyages didn’t respond to requests for comment. Royal Caribbean says the company doesn’t comment on individual deaths out of respect for crew privacy.)

Mariah Jocson

Morbid news continued into June. Mariah Jocson, a waitress from the Philippines stranded on Royal Caribbean’s Harmony of the Seas, which was docked in Barbados, was last seen asking a friend for a teapot. According to her father, on June 9 crew heard a code “Alpha” blared over the ship’s intercom system—shorthand for a medical emergency. Jocson was found hanged over her cabin’s balcony railing, police say.

Back on land, Krista Thomas, a former crew member living in Canada who’d started a Facebook group to advocate for seafarers during the pandemic, was receiving increasingly panicked private chats from distraught crew members. “I’d get messages like, ‘The doctor gave me anti-anxiety medicine, and my plan is to take the whole bottle,’ ” she says. She enrolled in an online suicide prevention course to learn how to respond.

Retaliating

Not all workers suffered in silence. In mid-May, acts of desperation erupted on several ships as workers tried to call attention to their plight. On Royal Caribbean’s Navigator of the Seas, crew members started a hunger strike to pressure the company to get them home faster. On the deck of Majesty of the Seas, another of the company’s ships, protesters raised a banner reading, “How many more suicides you need?!” Royal Caribbean says the company “understood the frustration behind the protest” and that the ships’ captains took steps to resolve each situation.

A social man

He’d been an assistant shore excursion manager on the Carnival Elation, a job that involved organizing touristy adventures in ports of call. In early March, a little over two months into Szaller’s contract, the Elation docked at Freeport in Grand Bahama for a few weeks of scheduled repairs. By this time, Covid outbreaks on several ships had resulted in scores of infections. “It was very scary,” says Jessica van Rooyen, a colleague of Szaller’s on the Elation. “You’d put on the news, and it’s all this horrific stuff.”

In mid-April, Szaller was transferred to Carnival Magic, where he remained in limbo for about two weeks. Some members of the crew, normally relegated to the lowest quarters of a ship, were allowed to move to now-vacant guest suites. But Szaller was stuck in a spartan staff cabin, according to his family. “He was effectively in a private cell,” says Vilmos, his father. “How would you feel if you were confined to a windowless cell and could only go out once or twice a day?”

Szaller passed the time in his cabin drinking red wine, or playing video games, or binging on TV shows he’d downloaded onto his laptop. He watched Breaking Bad, Dexter, and Modern Family. Otherwise his refuge was the smoking area of Deck 11, where he’d puff Marlboros and shoot the breeze with friends. But even getting cigarettes could be a pain: The line at the ship’s convenience store often snaked with more than 100 people. When his stash ran low, he joked that he’d happily trade his phone for just two more packs, Vilmos recalls.

Feeling isolated

In their conversations, Vilmos was struck not just by how isolated Jozsef seemed but also that he was kept in a “state of total uncertainty.” Back home in Hungary, the government had extended its nationwide lockdown indefinitely, which helped Vilmos “understand what my son was going through—what it’s like to feel enclosed.”

But Vilmos, an arborist for the city of Budapest, was confined at home for only three days before receiving permission to work outside again. (“They realized that it’d be kind of difficult to transport a massive tree to my house,” he jokes.) Jozsef, meanwhile, told his parents about Carnival’s ever-changing plans for him. First he was informed that he’d be home by Easter, but the date was postponed without explanation, then postponed again. He told his dad a co-worker was advised to pack a suitcase for a flight home, only to be sent back to his cabin at the last minute. Crew kept a close eye on a third-party travel app that listed plane tickets Carnival had booked in their names. A close friend of Jozsef’s says they saw about five different flights home issued for them and then canceled. A Carnival spokesperson says the company provided frequent updates to crew and blamed the reschedulings on constantly changing travel restrictions.

An effort to return home

Cruise operators ultimately decided to sail remaining employees to seaports in their continent of origin, where it’d be easier to get them home by land or air. In an effort to consolidate crew by home region, the Magic transferred European crew by lifeboat to the Carnival Breeze, which was set to travel to England. By May, Szaller had moved into a guest cabin on the Breeze with a window and, even better, a balcony. He told his dad he was happy to finally be able to see the sun and the sea from his room. He started making post-pandemic plans, telling friends and family he wanted to learn photography when he made it home. In the near term he would quarantine near Budapest in his parents’ weekend cottage. Colleagues say he never even hinted at being depressed. If anything, he’d tried to cheer others up.

Life on the Breeze that May was still structured—Carnival issued a precise timetable dictating when crew could leave their cabins for food or a twice-daily “60 min fresh air break.” Just as on land, people began to let their guard down, socializing more and worrying less about the virus. Everybody seemed to be at the ship’s bars a lot. “What else can you do?” Szaller’s close friend asks. “On Breeze, we had limited time to let the steam off. Without the alcohol, things could’ve been even worse.”

The day of the incident

On the evening of Wednesday, May 6, Szaller got drunk with a group before everybody went their separate ways. The close friend says that was the last night they saw Jozsef. He missed temperature checks that week and didn’t respond to texts. His body was found three days later. “I absolutely blame myself,” this friend says. “Even now, when I think about it, I feel responsible. How is it possible I didn’t see something like this would happen?”

Vilmos says his own grief was worsened by Carnival’s refusal to discuss the specific circumstances of his son’s death. He theorizes it’s in the company’s legal interest to disclose as little information as possible. He was especially rattled by their first call, when representatives said it was for his own “protection” not to go into detail about the matter. A Carnival spokesperson says that the company’s crew medical coordinator had at least 15 subsequent email exchanges with Vilmos, and that at no time did he indicate his questions weren’t being answered. Carnival says it suspended contact after learning of the family’s pending legal action.

Another mourning father

Like Vilmos Szaller, Cirilo Jocson is desperate for closure. His daughter, Mariah, was the waitress discovered hanged on a Royal Caribbean ship in June. “We just want to know how they found my daughter,” he says, sounding on the verge of tears. “Really, even just a photo of the crime scene. We need the truth.”

“She kept on telling me, Daddy, I will be home on this day, on this day, on this day,” he says. “The schedule was always changing.” He is still in disbelief over her passing. When asked if she ever showed signs of depression, he responds, “No, nothing, nothing, nothing, nothing at all.”

The search for answers

In the months that followed his son’s death, Vilmos says he contacted as many crewmates as possible to find out what happened. He’s frustrated that, as far as he knows, nobody from the ship’s management or medical staff bothered checking on Jozsef for several days after he began missing temperature checks. Carnival declined to comment on this matter.

In November, a coroner in Winchester, England, concluded that Jozsef had died due to hanging and suggested it was likely “an impulsive yet intentional and self-administered act under the influence of alcohol.” A previous postmortem examination of Jozsef’s body noted that his blood alcohol had been triple the legal driving limit. This last fact is a key point in the arbitration demand the Szallers filed. A Carnival spokesperson says its bartenders are trained to identify overindulgence and deny service accordingly. The Szaller family attorney, Holly Ostrov-Ronai, says the company should have known the hazards of isolating employees for indefinite periods and provided them with the appropriate mental health support—not “unfettered access” to booze, wine, and beer. “They allowed [employees] to purchase as much alcohol as they wanted, confined them to their little cabins, and then didn’t check on them,” she says. “They had a duty to make sure [employees] were safe physically and mentally.”