- The CII evaluates ships based on CO2 emissions, but faces criticisms for its methodology and lack of financial penalties.
- Legal disputes may arise if a compromise is not reached between owners and charterers to sustain the CII.
- The current BIMCO CII Clause has drawn criticism for disproportionate obligations and ambiguous language.
- Exploring alternative approaches, such as off-hire options and emissions trading, seeks to incentivize emission reductions while avoiding unintended consequences.
The CII Operations Clause presents a complex challenge for the shipping industry, requiring a delicate balance between environmental goals and commercial interests.
Challenge of Implementation
The CII Operations Clause, initiated by BIMCO and effective since January 2023, aims to reconcile shipping’s environmental and commercial interests by grading ships based on their annual Carbon Intensity Index (CII) performance. However, several issues arise, including disputes and criticisms regarding the index’s methodology and lack of financial penalties.
Disputes on the Horizon
Legal and contractual disputes may loom ahead for the shipping industry as it grapples with finding a fair compromise between owners and charterers to sustain the CII. The clause’s ambiguous language and potential financial burdens demand careful consideration and adaptation.
Challenges with the Clause
The current BIMCO CII Clause attempts to pre-agree on CII values and monitor performance during charters, but it faces criticism for disproportionately placing obligations on charterers and lacks clarity on issues such as demurrage and compliance breaches.
Seeking Alternative Approaches
Various alternative approaches have been suggested, from off-hire options for improving CII ratings to the implementation of an “emissions trading” style system. Exploring these solutions aims to incentivize both charterers and owners to address emissions concerns while avoiding unintended consequences.
Did you subscribe to our daily Newsletter?
It’s Free! Click here to subscribe!
Source-maritimeprofessional
