The Hellenic Bureau for Marine Casualties Investigation (HBMCI) was recently instituted as the competent body to conduct marine casualty investigations under Greek Law 4033/2011, which implements EU Directive 2009/18/EC as the framework for accident investigations in the marine transport sector, reports UKP&I.
The Hellenic Bureau
HBMCI investigations are limited to marine casualties or incidents involving commercial shipping. It specifically excludes warships or other types of ships owned or managed by the Greek and/or EU Member-States which are used on public non-commercial services (Art. 2 §3). As a consequence, the HBMCI is not able to investigate incidents involving these ships.
The HBMCI’s investigations are restricted to a factual analysis of an incident, without an allocation of fault. It is independent of any criminal, disciplinary, administrative, or civil investigations which may seek to determine or apportion liability. Thus, even where the Public Prosecutor appoints a surveyor for the same incident, any criminal investigation is conducted in parallel to, and independent from, the HBMCI. Indeed, the enabling language in the legislation creating the HBMCI evidences the intention that any HBCMI report made should not be used in judicial proceedings.
From a P&I perspective, one way to view the HBMCI is in a way similar to Loss Prevention. The HBMCI’s role is to identify the causal and contributing factors that led to a marine accident or incident, to avoid similar marine accidents in the future, thereby enhance maritime safety. It stands separate from any judicial assessment conducted by the courts or administrative bodies.
However, this does not stop parties in litigation seeking to rely on findings in an HBMCI report to bolster their case. Whilst this is certainly not the correct use of these reports, the HBMCI findings have been admitted as factual evidence in civil proceedings.
Given that the courts seem willing to overlook the intention that HBMCI reports are not used in litigation, unless and until there is an express prohibition on admitting the reports as evident, they should always be regarded as potentially influential in any civil proceedings.
Did you subscribe to our daily Newsletter?
It’s Free! Click here to Subscribe
Source: UKP&I
